Judge must stand corrected on Bonnie Dumanis’ conviction rate
I noted with interest the letter (April 10) from retired Justice Howard Wiener criticizing the computation of the conviction rate of District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis. It should first be noted that Wiener’s entire career has been spent on the “civil” or business side of the law, so his comments on the field of the practice of criminal law should be taken with a few grains of salt.
He quotes the fact that in the 15,567 convictions obtained from the filing of 16,406 cases (a 94 percent ratio), some were misdemeanors rather than felonies. If we adopt his assumption that every case filed in the year he cites was in fact completed, that means just 839 (only 5 percent) resulted in an acquittal or “not guilty” finding. I’d call that an outstanding record.
If we look at Wiener’s field of civil cases, any time an attorney wins a judgment for his client that’s a “win” — you don’t look at the size of the judgment or quibble about whether or not he or she won everything the client was seeking. Why would you do that in criminal cases?
Justice Wiener also suggests that DAs should be subject to term limits in their service. I served as a Deputy DA under two different DAs who each served with distinction for 24 years — James Don Keller (1947-1971) and Edwin L. Miller Jr. (1971-1995). They were both responsible for great reforms and innovations in the administration of justice in this county.
The facts reveal that the retired justice served on the Court of Appeals for 16 years — is he now suggesting that appellate justices should also be subject to term limits? u
Charles L. Patrick, La Jolla
Retired Deputy District Attorney
and Retired Judge of the Superior Court
- Opinion: Stop blaming SeaWorld for the seal colony at Children’s Pool in La Jolla
- Opinion / Letters to the Editor: Sharks are back in La Jolla because of the pinnipeds
- Our View: Keep fine-tuning, while advancing, Torrey Pines plans
- DA’s office adding information on criminal cases to website
- Opinion: Do something for the seals
Short URL: http://www.lajollalight.com/?p=123725