Owners of ‘Windemere’ property in La Jolla are suing city

Irving Gill’s potentially historic ‘Windemere’ cottage, as seen just a few years before its demolition. File

By Pat Sherman

The owners of the land on which Irving Gill’s “Windemere” cottage once stood have filed suit against the City of San Diego for preventing them from building a new home on their property at 1328 Virginia Way in La Jolla.

The San Diego City Council voted 5-3 on Sept. 23 to uphold the La Jolla Community Planning Association and La Jolla Historical Society’s (LJHS’s) appeal of a California Environmental Quality Act exemption issued by the city, which essentially allowed property owners Frank and Nina Bottini to demolish Gill’s 1894 cottage on Dec. 23, 2011 — ostensibly leaving a vacant parcel for the couple to build a more modern home.

In the two years since, challenges to the Windemere demolition have prevented the Bottinis from developing their property. Their suit charges that “the city council abused its discretion” because Windemere was not technically a historic resource (though the historical society says it was in the process of seeking an historic designation).

The demolition occurred after the City of San Diego declared Windemere to be unsafe and a public nuisance — a condition historic preservationists say was hastened by the property owners willfully exposing the home’s interior to the elements and removing some of its key historic features.

However, the suit states that “a public agency cannot order a structure to be demolished based upon a finding that it is a public nuisance, approve and issue a permit for the demolition of the structure, and then a year-and-a-half after the structure has been demolished, require an environmental review process that requires city staff to pretend the structure still exists and that is a historic resource. …

“The city council ignored the facts, the law and the factual findings and recommendations of the city’s own staff,” the suit states.

The Bottinis are demanding that the city set aside  the council resolution granting the environmental appeal of the Windemere demolition, and are seeking “damages arising from inverse condemnation” (when a government takes private property but fails to pay the required compensation).

Related posts:

  1. Windemere Saga Continues: City Council upholds appeal of La Jolla cottage demolition
  2. La Jolla News Nuggets: MESOM readies for opening, Cove cleanup, Windemere saga at City Council … and more
  3. La Jolla’s beach cottages: An issue of integrity
  4. La Jolla cottages survive another day as preservationists gain ground with the city
  5. La Jollans attend vigil for Irving Gill’s ‘Windemere’

Short URL: http://www.lajollalight.com/?p=117868

Posted by Pat Sherman on Dec 10, 2013. Filed under La Jolla, News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

1 Comment for “Owners of ‘Windemere’ property in La Jolla are suing city”

  1. Bill

    No, inverse condemnation is when the property owner, rather than the condemnor, initiates the action. It’s referred to as “inverse” because normally a government agency initiates condemnation proceedings — that is, the government says, “We want this property and this is what it’s worth.” In other words, eminent domain.

    In an inverse condemnation situation, the government regulates a property (or takes it) without considering it to be a taking for 5th Amendment purposes.

Leave a Reply

La Jolla Community Calendar


Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6

RSS North Coastal News

  • Carmel Valley resident wins $5.4 million verdict in high-profile case July 9, 2014
    Top San Diego trial lawyer and longtime Carmel Valley resident Robert J. Francavilla is a partner with CaseyGerry, where he has practiced law for more than 25 years, specializing in serious personal injury, head trauma and wrongful death. He most recently achieved a $5.4 million verdict against the U.S. government in a case involving a motorcyclist who was s […]
  • AutoMatters: Flower Power, Fireworks & Music at the Fair July 9, 2014
    The British are coming! The British are coming! The British were here – in a VW Beetle? I’ll explain shortly. For 24 days beginning in June and ending shortly after the Fourth of July, the San Diego County Fair was in town. As you may know, a couple of columns ago (in AutoMatters # 338) the Fair had terrific action-packed motorsports, car shows and more. I w […]
  • Former Torrey Pines pitching standout Joey DeNato finally gets his chance in pro ball July 9, 2014
    After concluding one of the most distinguished prep pitching careers in San Diego County history, former Torrey Pines High School standout Joey DeNato’s name never surfaced on the 2010 amateur draft board. The call finally came last month. After a stellar senior year at Indiana that was apparently too much for professional scouts to overlook, the Philadelphi […]