Future of Seal Cam monitoring at La Jolla Children’s Pool in limbo

Mayor Bob Filner addresses a crowd gathered above Children's Pool beach earlier this year heralding installation of the Seal Cam. File

By Pat Sherman

As the city prepares to demolish the old, condemned lifeguard tower at Children’s Pool beach, questions remain about the future of the Seal Cam mounted atop the old tower — particularly, who will be tasked with monitoring the streaming video used to file reports on the harbor seal colony there? And how much money will the city allocate for this service?

At the June 24 La Jolla Parks and Beaches meeting, Board Chair Dan Allen reported that in July the City of San Diego Park and Recreation department would assume operation of the Seal Cam at Children’s Pool beach, as stated in a monitoring plan issued by the city in May.

The city’s partner in the project, Sara Wan of the WAN Conservancy (which paid for the Seal Cam, its installation and some hired camera monitors) told La Jolla Light she believes her nonprofit organization will continue overseeing Seal Cam monitoring, though Lee Burdick, the mayor’s Director of Special Projects and Legal Affairs, said the city is still evaluating whether it is more cost effective to monitor the Seal Cam with city employees, or to outsource the job to WAN Conservancy.

Burdick said WAN Conservancy’s original estimate to continue monitoring the Seal Cam was $283,000 per year.

“We have asked them to go back and evaluate that in light of things like the beach being closed at night during pupping season,” Burdick said. “Do you really need to monitor (at night)? Would that cut costs?

“So they’re evaluating their budget. Then, once we get their budget, we’re going to have to look at the expenses that would be involved with the city doing it, and then figure out what is the most cost-effective way to do it for the citizens of San Diego.

“At the end of the day,” Burdick said, “it’s (up to) the city council as to whether they want to budget the money for that purpose and if they believe that’s a good use of the city’s dollars.”

The California Coastal Commission (CCC) required the monitoring plan as a condition for issuing a coastal development permit for the year-round guideline rope spanning Children’s Pool beach (intended to keep humans a safe distance from seals). The three-year plan requires that the city measure the number of seal harassment instances at Children’s Pool, including humans disrupting the marine mammals’ behavior patterns, including migration, breathing, nursing, breeding, feeding or sheltering.

The plan also states that “authorized data collectors” are instructed to report harassment observed via the Seal Cam, or shown to them in video or photograph form by random observers. Cases of harassment will be documented with other data — including the number and location of seals and humans on the beach at any given time — and submitted to the CCC’s executive director in an annual monitoring report, due one year to the date the CCC issued the coastal development permit (May 16, 2013).

According to the plan, data collectors will be trained by the park ranger assigned to Children’s Pool, and can include “any volunteers the ranger believes may be helpful in assisting in the data collection process” (wording which, presumably, allows for the use of those currently volunteering with, or in the employee of, the WAN Conservancy.)

“I believe that it’s important to preserve, for the city, the discretion to achieve the Coastal Commission’s goals in the most cost effective manner,” Burdick said of the language. “We wanted to get a permit that allowed the city some discretion in deciding how we meet those compliance obligations.”

CCC staff analyst Kanani Brown, told the Light the CCC board and its staff ecologist allowed for the use of volunteer monitors in the plan, due to the city’s “limited resources.”

“This is a three-year permit,” Brown said. “If the city would like to continue this permit beyond three years it will have to continue to submit those (annual) monitoring reports.”

Larry and Sara Wan of the Western Alliance for Nature (WAN) Conservancy at La Jolla Children's Pool. File

Mayor Bob Filner assured the camera would remain in operation at Children’s Pool beach during demolition of the old tower and construction of the new. On Monday, Burdick said the Seal Cam will be mounted atop a construction trailer that will occupy a row of parking spaces during the work.

Burdick said she is not sure whether the Seal Cam will be mounted atop the new tower, once complete, or in a different location.

“I think that’s what everyone is looking toward, but that is such a long way off,” she said. “Whether we will have budget allocation by that point, whether the city will acquire the camera at that point, whether city employees will take over monitoring, it’s impossible to predict. We’re just trying to get through the next three or four months to get things to a stable place, and then reevaluate what we need based on changing circumstances.”

Further confusion over funding

Mayor Bob Filner budgeted $50,000 for Seal Cam operations and monitoring in the city’s 2013-2014 fiscal year. Speaking with the La Jolla Light on June 28, Filner said the $50,000 was to cover the camera’s operational costs only and not to purchase the camera from the WAN Conservancy. “We are not purchasing it,” he said. “It’s theirs.”

The mayor said he was unaware of a banner ad that has been on WAN Conservency’s website for months soliciting donations to “help keep this webcam operating” — despite his participation in a fundraiser on April 25 at Mangelsen Gallery in La Jolla that Sara Wan said brought in $5,000 to cover some of WAN Conservancy’s $40,000 camera costs.

Sara Wan and her husband, Larry, declined to disclose how much they’ve raised for Seal Cam operations through their website banner thus far, though on July 8 Sara Wan told the Light the Conservancy had raised far less than $25,000. “It’s a losing proposition,” she said. “We have used our own money to get us to this point.”

Screen shot of a banner ad soliciting donations for the Seal Cam on the WAN Conservancy website, wan conservancy.org The nonprofit initially asked the City of San Diego for $283,000 a year to monitor the streaming footage with paid camera monitors, according to a spokesperson for the mayor's office.

She added that the amount would be made public as part of the organization’s next tax filing because, at present, the Wans feel the project has been unfairly scrutinized by media and pro-beach advocates.

Burdick said the city does not know how much WAN Conservancy has raised through its website, though she said at some point during their negotiations with the city, that amount would be disclosed.

“That, too, is going to have an impact on the negotiations,” she said. “Obviously, if they can get a grant to fully fund the thing, then the city might be off the hook to pay $50,000. But if they cannot and the mayor feels that this is a very valuable humanitarian service, we’re going to need to look at it and do that cost effectiveness comparison and analysis.”

Should the monitoring be done by paid city employees, Filner told the Light last week they could be from Park and Rec or City TV (the city’s municipal government cable access channel).

“The aim is to continue to try and operate (the camera) without the necessity of volunteers,” he said.

To date, Burdick said the city has paid no money to WAN Conservancy for the Seal Cam or related expenses.

“With respect to the $50,000 … we do anticipate some, if not all of that, will likely be paid to the WAN Conservancy to, first of all, relocate the camera during construction and continue to operate it,” she said. “How that money will be spent is currently in negotiation. We’re trying to set a scope of service. We’re looking at whether all of it will be necessary, or if additional funding will be necessary. … The only thing I am certain of is that the expenses associated with relocating it from the lifeguard tower to the construction trailer will be paid as part of that $50,000 budget allocation.”

Meanwhile, members of La Jolla’s Parks and Beaches (LJP&B), which has opposed the Seal Cam project since its installation, formed a subcommittee to draft a proposal for “improved” usage of the Seal Cam if and when Park and Rec staff takes over.

LJP&B will submit details of its proposal, which is now circulating among members for approval, to Park and Rec at a later date.

— Susan DeMaggio and Ashley Mackin contributed to this report.

Related posts:

  1. Questions arise about details of seal harassment video at La Jolla Children’s Pool
  2. Mayor shares details of recently installed ‘seal cam’ at La Jolla Children’s Pool
  3. Judge denies request to shorten seal rope at La Jolla Children’s Pool
  4. Updated with Video: Police ordered to ‘keep the peace’ at La Jolla Children’s Pool
  5. UPDATED (Jan. 25): Webcam to monitor seals installed at La Jolla Children’s Pool

Short URL: http://www.lajollalight.com/?p=109770

Posted by Pat Sherman on Jul 9, 2013. Filed under Featured Story, La Jolla, News, Seal Watch. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

9 Comments for “Future of Seal Cam monitoring at La Jolla Children’s Pool in limbo”

  1. Califia

    Looks like that gift horse (surveillance camera) should have had a full dental exam before it was put up. The “gift” to the City sure got expensive.

    Mayor Bob’s pet projects are killing San Diego’s budget. $283k/year to operate the camera. Are you kidding. But that’s just a drop in the bucket of money the City has spent to try to chase children out of their pool.

    • Cheryl Aspenleiter

      The Seal Camera is watching people and does not have that authority. Take it down now. It is abusive. Many many tourists are complaining about having their families filmed. Jane Reldan and her gang, actually video our guests within inches of their faces, kids too. And the camera IS following women into the showers. And honing in on license plates . This is clearly abusive. Someone told me that the Mayor has this the seal ( silkie{ camera on in his private office. We know he likes women. Is this is Peep Show? The camera is not appropriate on a Children’s Playground. The seal feces is not appropriate and the seals need to be moved out of there immediately. And the sand dredged and the breakwater wall repaired. The plan of the Mayor and his campaign contributors the WAN Couple and their GANG of ruffians who frighten children and famlies to tears and worry about where photos of their young daughters are going. This is a pool for the Disabled and our Wounded Warriors need this therapy pool very much. For San Diego to give back to the VETS is approprate and is a way to honor them. There is no better therapy than this ocean pool. It keeps me alive. But it needs to be cleaned. And the seals taken out to the Channel Islands where the underwater ecology can support them possibly. Sea World needs to quit rescuing them, ( at several thousand dollars each its a racket) and let the sharks eat them, so their numbers balance out and the ocean can balance out along our coastline. If the seals populations were reduced the ecology would have a chance to recover. People if you love seals then you must in turn love the ocean their home. The Ocean is all about balance .
      Thank you . Please Support the Complete Restoration of the Childrens Pool to be the best ADA Ocean Therapy Pool in the World. It would be a destination not just a stop off point to look at seals pooping. This beach is for people first and foremost and fecal bacteria should not be allowed ever.
      The seals would always swim in , but with the sand dredged out there would be no room to haul out and they would go elsewhere where the surf washes away the feces and urine and after birth. Does that make sense to you? No mammal should ever live in its own filth. Bacteria causes fatal illness to seals.

  2. resident

    The city should not be empowering the very same “environmental” groups that are currently in breach of their permit by how this camera is being used… to spy on your children, women in bikini’s, people on the sidewalk which is completely out of range of the seals, etc… So far all Mayor Filner has done is empower the very fringe groups who have been manipulating our city and legal system for years… and now he wants to give them our tax dollars… so they can further their agenda of disregarding the laws and Ellen Browning Scripps trust that protect human access to this ONE OF A KIND, the ONLY man-made structure of its kind in the coastal United States. psssshhhh… blasphemy! Filner, you should choose your allies more carefully and actually do your own research regarding the laws you have sworn to govern by.

    • Cheryl Aspenleiter

      Hello Everyone, Hello??? The Children’s Pool is first and foremost a pool for little tiny kids to learn to swim. And equally important it is a therapy pool for the disabled. Hello La Jolla Light?? Hello City of San Diego??? We are a Military City are we not? We have the one and only ocean swimming pool in the Cont. United States do we not? Good. Stay with me here, its not that hard. ……
      We have now 16,000 newly severely disabled warriors coming home from those wars you all think are so important…. With out arms and legs, many missing multiple limbs. The Children’s Pool IS for sure without a doubt the only safe real ocean entry with a protected breakwater allowing for wheelchairs to enter and paraplegics to lift themselves out of their wheelchair life into the freedom of the calm pool. Do you understand now? The seals have all their body parts people!!! They can manuver the surf, they love their rip tide ride by their Seal Rock. They can access hundreds of beaches . They are in fact excellent swimmers. Friends of the Seals and the Mayor must now realize this. Guess what? The Disabled need the breakwater. That trumps seals people. Nothing against seals , no not a seal hater, I am known as The Woman Who Swims with Seals. They are my swim buddies. They swim to me. They do not need help and it is wrong for them to be penned in like that in their own waste. It actually caused miscarriage and stillbirths and the filth is terrible for us. Hey did you know that its a Kids Pool and Judge Pate ordered that sand dredged out, we are still waiting.

  3. For the rope permit research, the City is obligated ONLY to make 3 observations, 10 am, 1 pm and 4pm, at least 16 days of every month.. Count the seals, count the people, note the tide, the weather, whatnot.. The ranger could do it with no impact on his hours and so zero cost. The cam was run 24/7 by volunteers hoping to catch evidence useable to close the beach. They can keep on doing that for free if it is so important.

  4. Whats the purpose of monitoring it so tightly?

  5. neighbor

    Ask the taxpayers of san diego if they want to pay for a camera watching seals.
    People….. Please!
    There is No need for a camersato watch this beach! Is it for protection of the seals and activists?? Is it for the public’s good? Something smells here, and it’s not just the bird and seal poop!

  6. nemo

    A new $3M lifeguard tower, staffed by San Diego’s finest, watching a closed and empty beach!

  7. The cost of this camera is $238K and there is no way the City of San Diego can afford that. These crazy seal activists presented a video to the City of San Diego and the California Coastal Commission claiming beach users were throwing rocks at the Seal Cam. The San Diego Police Department dismissed the vandalism claim after reviewing the video. Perhaps the CIty of San Diego needs to provide mental health services to these seal activist wack jobs.

Leave a Reply

La Jolla Community Calendar


Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6

RSS North Coastal News

  • Balkan folk music on tap Aug. 27 at Carmel Valley library August 20, 2014
    A special free family program of Balkan folk music, sponsored by the Friends of the Carmel Valley Library will be presented at 7 p.m. Wednesday, Aug. 27 in the library’s community room. […]
  • Del Mar bodysurfer winner at world championships August 20, 2014
    Dr. Chris Lafferty, 56, of the Del Mar BodySurfing Club won first place in the 2014 World Bodysurfing Championships in the Mens 55-64 years age division. […]
  • Fall Ball program coming to North Coast area August 20, 2014
    BaseballASAP is pleased to announce that it is offering a 2014 North Coastal Fall Ball program to serve Carmel Valley, Del Mar, Solana Beach, Rancho Santa Fe, Cardiff, Encinitas, and Carlsbad. […]