Rotting seaweed poses no danger

By Ashley Mackin

In a recent letter to the La Jolla Light, Bird Rock resident Karyn Meyer asked about the rotting seaweed found on the beach near her home. Her concerns included the cleanup of said seaweed and whether the gases emitted were toxic and dangerous to breathe. The area she specified was near Searidge Drive and Chelsea Street, north of Tourmaline beach.

Seaweed near Bird Rock emits a "rotten egg smell," but no harmful gases. Ashley Mackin

As promised, The Light did some investigating about her concerns.

Dr. Russ Vetter, Director of the Fisheries Resources Division of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, said it is common for large amounts of organic debris, such as seaweed and kelp, to die this time of year. However, he added, “This year there has been a large pulse in organic debris.”

Speaking of behalf of the Scripps Institute of Oceanography, assistant director of communications, Mario Aguilera, confirmed through his sources that the gas emitted from rotting seaweed is hydrogen sulfide, which is classified as toxic. An SIO scientist, who asked not to be named, said the higher temperatures of the summer months in- crease the rate of bacterial decay, therefore more of a ”rotten egg smell” is emitted. He said that Scripps does not monitor or study the level of hydrogen sulfide in the air.

The San Diego Air Pollution Control District also does not monitor hydrogen sulfide concentration levels along the beaches because it focuses on factories and businesses. Air Pollution Control Officer Robert Kard said he has experience with hydrogen sulfide through other avenues, and ex- plained that the conditions at Bird Rock do not yield harmful levels. He explained hydrogen sulfide has a “low-odor threshold,” meaning humans can smell it, even in low concentrations.

He also said in open, ventilated space, such as at Bird Rock beach- es, the concentration of hydrogen sulfide in the air is not harmful.

Acknowledging the “rotten egg smell,” Kard said in closed spaces, such as sewers, hydrogen sulfide could be harmful, but not in a beach setting.

Dan Daneri, District Manager for Shoreline Parks, a division of San Diego Park and Recreation, said the rocky area where much of the seaweed rots cannot be accessed with parks’ machinery; therefore Shoreline Parks does not clean that area. Seaweed and other debris are removed from areas to which they have access.

However, Daneri said the smell becomes less of a problem when the temperature drops, and the rate of decay decreases.

Vetter’s advice is to not disturb or move the seaweed to avoid the release of more hydrogen sulfide. Additionally, he said, it is the wave patterns in San Diego that disturb the seaweed in the water, furthering the release and carrying it to shore.

“Our typical onshore flows, the ones that make San Diego so pleasant, carry the hydrogen sulfide to shore,” Vetter said.

Related posts:

  1. Scientists converge in La Jolla to discuss rising sea levels
  2. Tar balls reported near Scripps Pier
  3. UCSD professor appointed to state tobacco oversight committee
  4. La Jollans rally for teens hurt in crash as Cass Street Cafe reopens
  5. Scripps Health starts work on proton therapy center

Short URL:

Posted by Ashley Mackin on Sep 26, 2012. Filed under Health & Science, La Jolla, News, Outdoors. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

5 Comments for “Rotting seaweed poses no danger”

  1. Joe LaCava

    I am convinced the smell is not the seaweed but the large storm drain pipe that comes out of the bluff at that corner. We have been down to the beach when the smell was awful at our house a block away, no smell from the seaweed but the storm drain pipe outlet sure was stinky. My guess is rotting debris and standing water inside the pipe.

  2. Guest

    Perhaps officials should take this situation a little more seriously.! See the url below
    Toxic algae poison French beaches, kill horse
    A French government-sponsored report released Thursday says decomposing algae covering some beaches in Brittany represent a serious health risk and gases that can kill within minutes were detected on a beach where a horse died last month.

    • Guest

      I agree with the above guest's comment. If you read the posted article from the Seattle Times, you can't ignore the possibility that our "Stank Bank" might, in fact, be quite dangerous.

  3. Ashley Mackin

    Thank you for your comments. Algae and seaweed are not exactly the same thing, though they are in the same family. Algae (and the gases it gives off), as found in France, is much more harmful. Seaweed is actually mass produced for it's benefits to humans and as a fertilizer. Thanks for reading!

  4. Another Guest

    I feel so much better now that someone from the government, who doesn't live with the smell, says not to worry about the fumes. So comforting they are watching out for us.

Leave a Reply

La Jolla Community Calendar


Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6

RSS North Coastal News

  • Congregation Beth Am Labor Day Picnic September 2, 2014
    Congregation Beth Am held a festive Labor Day Picnic Sept. 1. This year is the 31st anniversary of this synagogue that started in a tire store in Solana Beach. […]
  • Suspects attempt to rob Solana Beach bank ATM September 2, 2014
    An attempt to break into an ATM at a Solana Beach bank branch early Sept. 2 using a cutting torch ended with the cash machine in flames and two suspects fleeing empty-handed. The suspects set off the ATM's alarm during the failed heist shortly after 2:30 a.m. in the 600 block of Lomas Santa Fe Drive near Glencrest Drive, according to sheriff's Lt. […]
  • First phase of Earl Warren Middle School reconstruction begins in Solana Beach September 2, 2014
    As kids kicked back this summer, San Dieguito Union High School District kicked off the first phase of its complete reconstruction of Earl Warren Middle School. The $41 million project is made possible by the passage of Proposition AA. […]