Judge sends seal rope matter back to Planning Commission

With the rope down, families have been on the beach at the children's pool. Photo: Giovanni Moujaes

By Dave Schwab
Staff Writer

Superior Court Judge Lisa Foster on Friday sent the matter of the rope barrier at La Jolla’s Children’s Pool back to the city Planning Commission, asking them to clarify what constitutes “encroachment.”

Foster, however, said her decision “does not mean the rope goes back up because there’s no permit in place.”

Foster also seriously questioned whether the courtroom was the appropriate venue to decide whether the rope barrier separating humans from seals at the pool should be up and for how long.

“This is quintessentially a political issue now,” she said. “I think this belongs back in City Hall, not in the Hall of Justice.”

Foster noted there are two distinct groups with competing views of how the pool as a public resource should best be used. Local government is the best arena in which to frame that debate, she said.

An animal rights groups, the Animal Protection and Rescue League (APRL), was in Foster’s court challenging a ruling by the city Planning Commission that had reversed an earlier decision by the City Council that supported a year-round rope at Children’s Pool.

The mostly visual barrier is put up from mid-December to mid-May during the marine mammals’ pupping season. Animal rights advocates insist it should be up year-round to protect seals from what they say is ongoing human encroachment.

Foster noted tongue-in-cheek that there is an analytical gap “the size of the Grand Canyon” in the Planning Commission’s decision that the rope barrier during pupping season doesn’t constitute encroachment into the public’s right-of-way on the beach, yet it does constitute encroachment the rest of the time.

“The Planning Commission needs to address this gap in their reasoning,” she concluded.
The judge also said there was other procedural confusion that needs to be clarified as to why the Planning Commission’s decision denying the year-round barrier is not appealable to the California Coastal Commission.

APRL attorney Bryan Pease warned that if the Planning Commission makes the same decision it did before that the case “may end up back here again (court).”

“I hope that is not the case,” replied Judge Foster.

Related posts:

  1. La Jolla seal debate goes back to court on Thursday
  2. City Council votes 6-0 to ban dogs at Children’s Pool
  3. Children’s Pool rope barrier goes up, but only for pupping season
  4. Planning Commission denies year-round rope barrier for La Jolla Children’s Pool
  5. City restricts First Amendment sellers at Children’s Pool

Short URL: http://www.lajollalight.com/?p=45959

Posted by Staff on Jul 15, 2011. Filed under Featured Story, La Jolla, News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

2 Comments for “Judge sends seal rope matter back to Planning Commission”

  1. npk32

    "'This is quintessentially a political issue now,' she said. 'I think this belongs back in City Hall, not in the Hall of Justice.'"

    Unfortunately, our elected officials are too busy figuring out whether or not the Real World house has their lights on too bright at night to give this issue any real thought.

  2. Seal Team 6

    660. As used in this chapter:
    (a) "Highway" includes all, or any part, of the entire width of
    the right-of-way of a state highway, whether or not the entire area
    is actually used for highway purposes.
    (b) "Encroachment" includes any tower, pole, pole line, pipe, pipe
    line, fence, billboard, stand or building, or any structure, object
    of any kind or character not particularly mentioned in this section,
    or special event, which is in, under, or over any portion of the
    highway. "Special event" means any street festival, sidewalk sale,
    community-sponsored activity, or community-approved activity.

Leave a Reply

La Jolla Community Calendar


Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6

RSS North Coastal News

  • Summer 2014 Carmel Valley Open Basketball League Champs: ‘Carmel Valley Spurs’ August 30, 2014
    On Aug. 18, the Carmel Valley Spurs defeated the Solana Beach Stray Cats, 67-41, in the 5th/6th grade championship game in the Master Sports Carmel Valley OPEN Basketball League. Over a 10-game season, the offense scored 659 points while giving up only 364 on defense. The average game score was 66-36. They had the best rebounders, best shooters, and best def […]
  • Hundreds turn out for Carmel Valley planning board meeting on One Paseo August 30, 2014
    Hearts and visions collided at the Aug. 28 Carmel Valley Community Planning Board meeting, where an overflow crowd turned out to debate the future of the last major slice of the community left to be developed. All 400 seats in Canyon Crest Academy’s theater were filled, and people spilled out into the aisles and crammed into standing-room only spots in the b […]
  • Del Mar Library book-to-movie club picks fall reads August 30, 2014
    Print Goes to the Movies, a book/movie discussion group held at the Del Mar Branch Library at 2 p.m. every second Friday, has announced its upcoming dates and movies. […]