Appellett Court rules on city’s deferred pension plan

City News Service

The City Attorney’s Office and San Diego Police Officers Association both claimed at least a partial victory today in an appellate court decision involving a deferred retirement program.

The city and POA sued each other over the program known as “DROP,”
developed in 1997 to allow employees to officially retire but remain on the payroll for up to five years while pension benefits accumulate in a special account. City officials at the time billed it as a way to retain experienced workers.

DROP, which was not supposed to cost the city extra money, was blamed for rising pension costs and eliminated for new hires in 2005. The city also
lowered interest rates and raised the eligibility age for the program to reduce

Two years ago, Superior Court Judge David Oberholtzer denied a preliminary injunction request by the POA and, without ruling on substantive issues, ordered the two sides to negotiate.

The POA, which also wants DROP to be defined as a vested benefit that cannot be taken away, appealed, but Tuesday’s ruling for the most part was a rejection of its arguments.

A three-judge panel of the 4th District Court of Appeals did say that the city made DROP permanent in 2002 and reiterated that position four times in subsequent memorandums of understanding with the POA.

POA President Brian Marvel said the appellate panel “expressly noted” that DROP was a retirement benefit made permanent by the city.

City Attorney Jan Goldsmith opined that the ruling left no more need for litigation.

“This appellate decision reaffirms our advice that the city has the ability to make the DROP program cost-free by reducing the interest rate, requiring participants to contribute toward the pension costs and changing salaries,” Goldsmith said. “The City Council is empowered to solve the DROP problem.”

The appellate justices ordered the case returned to Superior Court for a determination of the substantive issues surrounding DROP.

Related posts:

  1. City Council favors cutting DROP costs
  2. City leaders offer to meet with employees over pension issues
  3. Pair sentenced for selling fake Comic-Con tickets
  4. Holiday travelers advised to plan ahead
  5. Ceremonies to inaugurate new Miramar cemetery set for Monday

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Apr 13, 2011. Filed under News, Region. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply

La Jolla Community Calendar


Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6

RSS North Coastal News

  • Motorcyclist killed in accident near Del Mar Fairgrounds July 21, 2014
    The motorcyclist killed in a two-vehicle crash near the Del Mar Fairgrounds over the weekend was identified July 21 as a 22-year-old Escondido man. Alexander Mackenzie Williams was headed west on Via de la Valle near Jimmy Durante Boulevard at a high rate of speed shortly before 6:30 p.m. Sunday, July 20, when he lost control and swerved into oncoming traffi […]
  • Bestselling author Jojo Moyes discusses her novels with fans at Del Mar Country Club luncheon July 21, 2014
    “On my last book tour, I had a day off in Portland and it was very nice,” said bestselling novelist Jojo Moyes at a luncheon recently held at the Del Mar Country Club. Then she paused, looked around and added, “But I can tell you a day off in La Jolla is better.” The British author definitely knows how to please an audience – as evidenced not just by the war […]
  • Solana Beach employee featured at City Hall Gallery July 21, 2014
    From Monday through Friday, David Kloz works as a management analyst for the city of Solana Beach. When he’s not at work, Kloz is often outside with a camera. A collection of his photos is currently on exhibit at his workplace, the Solana Beach City Hall. It’s the amateur photographer’s first ever show. “I’m curious to see what the response is going to be,” […]