City Council favors cutting DROP costs

By James R. Riffel
City News Service

A majority of the City Council expressed support Monday for lowering the city’s costs for a controversial deferred retirement program that a consultant said could cost the deficit-ridden municipality nearly $150 million in the coming years.

Most of the council members said they wanted bring into line the costs and savings of the program, referred to as DROP, instead of eliminating it outright.

DROP was adopted in 1997 to keep experienced employees on the job instead of retiring or taking work elsewhere.

The study by Buck Consultants presented to council members Monday concludes that the city will spend 1.6 percent more on retiree expenses than if
DROP did not exist, to the tune of $148.7 million.

“We have a fiduciary responsibility to make this cost-free,” council President Tony Young said, adding that such an effort should not be used to “bludgeon” city employees.

The program allows employees to officially retire but remain on the payroll for up to five years while pension benefits accumulate in a special account.

The workers contribute 3 percent of their payroll to the account, which is matched by the city. The accounts are also guaranteed a 2.9 percent interest rate and 2 percent annual cost-of-living adjustment.

The workers cannot touch the retirement benefits until they leave city employment for good, and once they enroll their benefits no longer accrue.

The city is paying out less for retiree health under DROP, but those savings are more than offset by higher costs in pension payments, salaries and wages, and Medicare taxes. Those negative impacts happen because employees enrolled in DROP are generally older and higher-paid than their colleagues.

According to the city’s Independent Budget Analyst, 89 percent of the additional costs are tied up in employee salaries.

About 6,800 city workers were eligible for DROP as of June 30, 2009. Employees hired after June 30, 2005, are ineligible for the program.

The report listed a number of options for making DROP cost-free to the city, including restricting eligibility, eliminating the matching contribution and ending the cost-of-living increases.

Councilmen Todd Gloria and David Alvarez defended the program.

“We benefit from institutionalized memory,” said Gloria, who said that in his district, there are only a few workers who know how to perform certain maintenance functions in Balboa Park.

The city otherwise does not make a massive investment” in its employees, Gloria said.

A notable DROP opponent was Councilman Carl DeMaio.

“It boggles the mind that we’re considering continuing this instead of eliminating it,” DeMaio said.

Councilwoman Lorie Zapf said “ditto” to DeMaio’s comments and called DROP “overly generous.”

City Attorney Jan Goldsmith said San Diego has already won some DROP- related court cases, so adjustments should be based on issues that have already been litigated.

Chief Operating Officer Jay Goldstone said Mayor Jerry Sanders will have Buck Consulting study alternatives for lowering the city’s costs and bring them to the council in 30-45 days. Those proposals would then have to be presented to municipal labor unions for bargaining before they’re adopted.

Related posts:

  1. Faulconer re-elected as City Council president pro-tem
  2. Tony Young chosen as new City Council president
  3. San Diego considers privatizing more city services
  4. COO: If tax measure fails, city faces $23 million in cuts
  5. Council postpones hearing on sales-tax measure

Short URL:

Posted by Staff on Mar 8, 2011. Filed under News, Region. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

Leave a Reply

La Jolla Community Calendar


Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6

RSS North Coastal News

  • ‘Downton Abbey’ Spring Tea to be held by Del Mar Community Connections April 18, 2014
    All things “Downton Abbey”— from ‘20s tunes to exotic teas — will be featured as Del Mar Community Connections holds its annual spring tea on Wednesday, April 23, at St. Peter’s Parish Hall, 324 14th St., Del Mar. The 2-4 p.m. event includes music from the “Downton” era performed by entertainers “Janet and Jay” and piano music provided by Lori Ritman, who al […]
  • Week in sports for Carmel Valley, Solana Beach and Del Mar April 18, 2014
    Cathedral Catholic extended its winning streak to 11 games as the Dons opened Western League play with a 7-2 victory over Patrick Henry on April 9. The victory followed a 7-4 nonleague win against Mater Dei Catholic two days earlier. Will Law had three hits including a home run and a double and drove in four runs to lead the Dons in the Patrick Henry game. […]
  • Man pleads guilty in fatal Del Mar hit-and-run case April 17, 2014
    A man who drove drunk and struck a marine biologist in a crosswalk in Del Mar, then fled the scene, pleaded guilty April 16 to gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated and a hit-and-run allegation. Christopher ``Chip’’ Stockmeyer, 41, faces between nine and 15 years in prison when he is sentenced June 20 for the March 28 death of Rachel Morrison. […]