Fireworks displays along San Diego’s coastline debated

By Dave Schwab
Staff Writer

Players largely reiterated their stances on a tentative order that could make it a lot harder — and expensive — to host fireworks over water  potentially threatening community-oriented Fourth of July displays like the one held annually at La Jolla Cove.

Environmentalists and representatives of the fireworks industry and communities and organizations hosting fireworks displays over bodies of water crossed swords again at a two-hour public workshop Dec. 16 at the California Regional Qater Quality Control Board of San Diego in Kearny Mesa. The workshop was an opportunity to comment on Tentative Order No. R9-2010-0124, originally released on Sept. 23, 2010.

The Fourth of July fireworks display in La Jolla continued in 2010 despite a legal challenge. Photo: Brittany Comunale

The San Diego Water Board is currently fine-tuning that tentative order but had not completed the process. Water board staff added a final decision on the order, which stiffens requirements for hosting fireworks displays over water as well as charging a $1,452 fee per event.

The board is likely to hold another public workshop on the tentative order in late January before making a final decision on new tougher regulations in March or April of 2011.

In opening remarks, water board executive officer David Gibson explained the worshop’s purpose.

“The tentative order is itself a work in progress and this is the right time for the regional board which is charged with regulating pollutants discharged along the coast,” he said, adding fireworks debris unquestionably carries metals and other toxic debris that could potentially pollute water.

Gibson said the water board intends to “level the playing field” for all fireworks “players.”

“Whether fireworks are discharged over Santee or Dana Point, there should be the same rules,” he said.

Roger Schneider, a pyrotechnics expert and consultant for the fireworks industry, recited a long list of toxic chemicals, at the end of which he said, “I put them in my mouth, chewed and swallowed — it was broccoli coated with vinaigrette dressing” The point being, he added, that we’re surrounded by toxic chemicals which, in minute quantities, are beneficial not harmful.

That analogy Schneider likened to once-a-year fireworks displays which he argued leave only traces of harmful chemicals in the environment.

“I need to ask you (water board) how much (toxic) is there?” he asked. “You need to keep an eye on quantification.”

Environmental attorney Marco Gonzalez, who unsuccessfully attempted last year to block La Jolla’s Fourth of July display arguing all necessary permitting had not been obtained, said opponents of the new proposed tighter restrictions for fireworks permitting and water-quality monitoring are obscuring the facts.

“There is a patriotic notion that fireworks over water makes us feel more American,” he said, noting the Clean Water Act specifies harmful chemicals like those found in fireworks are required to be monitored by law in the environment. “We don’t want to but we will go to court to sue each and every municipality that violates the Clean Water Act. Don’t regulate (fireworks). We’re more than happy to resolve these issues in court.”

City Councilwoman Sherri Lightner, whose First District includes La Jolla, cautioned the water board to consider “the frequency of fireworks displays,” as well as the potential for “a huge (negative) impact on the economy, tourism and tax revenues” caused by barring them.

Related posts:

  1. Challenged Athletes Foundation events heading for La Jolla
  2. Wet weather didn’t dampen spirits at Splash Bash
  3. Kudos for polishing the Jewel: La Jolla Yoga Center
  4. LJ Shores underwater photo contest takes off
  5. Planned SIO research building worries neighbors

Short URL:

Posted by Dave Schwab on Dec 17, 2010. Filed under Featured Story, La Jolla, News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

1 Comment for “Fireworks displays along San Diego’s coastline debated”

  1. Sara

    Good Lord, Dave –

    Way to butcher Marco's comment. Sure, CERF will sue if necessary, and stronger requirements will probably result from the litigation than if everyone works collaboratively. The misrepresentations of LJ Light, and particularly your columns, are laughable.

Leave a Reply

La Jolla Community Calendar


Bottom Buttons 1

Bottom Buttons 2

Bottom Buttons 3

Bottom Buttons 4

Bottom Buttons 5

Bottom Buttons 6

RSS North Coastal News

  • Surf Soccer Club Academy GU9 team tops in division at 2014 Albion Cup July 25, 2014
    The Surf Soccer Club Academy GU9 team took first place in the 2014 Albion Cup (Girls U9 Cup) on July 18-21. They beat Carlsbad United’s top GU9 team in the semi-finals and went on to shut out Strikers FC in the finals, 4-0. Awesome tournament play by the entire team! […]
  • Surf Academy Select BU9 win it all at Albion Cup July 25, 2014
    San Diego Surf Academy Select BU9 won it all at the Albion Cup July 19-21! After winning their Showcase division by going unbeaten all weekend, they defeated Legends FC 4-1 in the finals on Monday. This is the second year in a row this team has won the Albion Cup. […]
  • Pushing boundaries July 24, 2014
    Few issues cause parents more distress than changes in school boundaries. Who can forget the tumult when in 2002 the Del Mar Union School District moved hundreds of families from one attendance area to another? Resentment still lingers, 12 years later. The San Dieguito Union High School District created its system of boundaries nearly 18 years ago that has w […]